Hey this is fire boy 11 and the topic at hand today is "Rock vs. Hip Hop/Pop". A recent trend among a lot of people i know (actually this has been happening for quite a while) is that many of them are switching to listening to hip hop or pop music. I myself prefer rock music. I have a number of reasons for this but we will come to that in a bit. I prefer old rock. Among the bands i liste to are Guns n Roses (formed in the 1980's), Aerosmith (formed in the 70's), the Beatles(formed in the 60's) and many such bands.
The following are some of the reasons as to why i prefer rock. The first thing that i prefer in rock music over hip hop/pop is the lyrics.The lyrics in hip hop songs are repetetive and tend to get tiresome. Most hip hop songs have one or more of the following topics- sex, drugs or alcohol. There is very little variety regarding the content of the lyrics. Lets take for example the song candy shop by 50 cent. The lyrics go -
I'll take you to the candy shop
I'll let you lick the lollipop
Go 'head girl, don't you stop
Keep going 'til you hit the spot (woah)
This content wise i dont think is very much different to lollipop by Lil Wayne which has the following lyrics -
she lick me like a lollipop
she lick me like a lollipop
she lick me like a lollipop
So I let her lick the wrapper
Like a lollipop
Now let us turn our attention to rock. Two songs which have similar lyrics are Summer of 69 by Brian Adams and All Summer Long by Kid Rock.However even here the content is very different. The chorus of Summer of 69 goes as follows -
Standin' on your mama's porch
You told me it would last forever
Oh the way you held my hand
I knew that it was now or never
Those were the best days of my life
Back in the summer of '69
Wheras the chorus of All Summer Long is -
And we were trying different things
We were smoking funny things
Making love out by the lake to our favorite song
Sipping whiskey out the bottle, not thinking 'bout tomorrow
Singing Sweet home Alabama all summer long
Singing Sweet home Alabama all summer long
Though both singers talk about certain memorable periods in their life the songs are different.
So what i am trying to get at is many hip hop songs tend to have similar lyrics. Rock on the other hand is vast. Bands write about politics (American Idiot by Green Day), aspirations (Rockstar by Nickleback), death (Knockin on Heavens Foor by Bob Dylan) and a lot of other topics.
Right so so far we have talked about repetition of content. Another thig that ticks me off about hip hop/pop is that inspite of the lack of lyrical quality it requires a lot of other people to write it. For example Party in the USA which was sung by Miley Cyrus was in fact written by five other guys. These guys get no recognition whatsoever. Further with the advent of "auto tune" even a mediocre singer can sound very good. Therefore i ask if neither the lyrics or the song is original then why are these artists getting so much recognition?
Thirdly i personally feel that rock musicains have more talent that hip hop artists (with a few exceptions here and there). I'll Tell you why in a minute. A rock band has three main instrmental components. The bass guitar, the lead guitar and the drums. To add to this is the vocals. Hip hop is mainly mainly lyrics which may or may not rhyme and a beat.At this point i would like to put out a general question. Has anyone tried playng the drums/bass/guitar? i play the guitar and have played the drums. Its not all that easy in the begining. But im suure i could work out a beat and make a rhyme. Thats why i feel rock musicains are more talented.
The next reason as to why i prefer rock is it has more variety. There are a lot of forms of rock. Alternate, hard rock progressive etc. Lastly the impact of a good rock song is longer lasting. For example a lot of people listen to the Beatles which were big in the 60's. The song I know you want me by Pitbull was quite popular a year back but barely anyone listens to it that much anymore.
There those are the reasons as to why i prefer rock music to hip hop/pop. Dint get me ewrong i still listen to hop hop songs and i even like some of the its just that i like rock uch better. Iveput up a poll make sure u vote. If you agree with me tell me so. If you dont tell me why im wrong and give me solid reasons as to why you think so. Even better make a post on this on your blog and paste the link as a comment. If you liked the post follow me, spread the word and do all that good stuff :)
The following are some of the reasons as to why i prefer rock. The first thing that i prefer in rock music over hip hop/pop is the lyrics.The lyrics in hip hop songs are repetetive and tend to get tiresome. Most hip hop songs have one or more of the following topics- sex, drugs or alcohol. There is very little variety regarding the content of the lyrics. Lets take for example the song candy shop by 50 cent. The lyrics go -
I'll take you to the candy shop
I'll let you lick the lollipop
Go 'head girl, don't you stop
Keep going 'til you hit the spot (woah)
This content wise i dont think is very much different to lollipop by Lil Wayne which has the following lyrics -
she lick me like a lollipop
she lick me like a lollipop
she lick me like a lollipop
So I let her lick the wrapper
Like a lollipop
Now let us turn our attention to rock. Two songs which have similar lyrics are Summer of 69 by Brian Adams and All Summer Long by Kid Rock.However even here the content is very different. The chorus of Summer of 69 goes as follows -
Standin' on your mama's porch
You told me it would last forever
Oh the way you held my hand
I knew that it was now or never
Those were the best days of my life
Back in the summer of '69
Wheras the chorus of All Summer Long is -
And we were trying different things
We were smoking funny things
Making love out by the lake to our favorite song
Sipping whiskey out the bottle, not thinking 'bout tomorrow
Singing Sweet home Alabama all summer long
Singing Sweet home Alabama all summer long
Though both singers talk about certain memorable periods in their life the songs are different.
So what i am trying to get at is many hip hop songs tend to have similar lyrics. Rock on the other hand is vast. Bands write about politics (American Idiot by Green Day), aspirations (Rockstar by Nickleback), death (Knockin on Heavens Foor by Bob Dylan) and a lot of other topics.
Right so so far we have talked about repetition of content. Another thig that ticks me off about hip hop/pop is that inspite of the lack of lyrical quality it requires a lot of other people to write it. For example Party in the USA which was sung by Miley Cyrus was in fact written by five other guys. These guys get no recognition whatsoever. Further with the advent of "auto tune" even a mediocre singer can sound very good. Therefore i ask if neither the lyrics or the song is original then why are these artists getting so much recognition?
Thirdly i personally feel that rock musicains have more talent that hip hop artists (with a few exceptions here and there). I'll Tell you why in a minute. A rock band has three main instrmental components. The bass guitar, the lead guitar and the drums. To add to this is the vocals. Hip hop is mainly mainly lyrics which may or may not rhyme and a beat.At this point i would like to put out a general question. Has anyone tried playng the drums/bass/guitar? i play the guitar and have played the drums. Its not all that easy in the begining. But im suure i could work out a beat and make a rhyme. Thats why i feel rock musicains are more talented.
The next reason as to why i prefer rock is it has more variety. There are a lot of forms of rock. Alternate, hard rock progressive etc. Lastly the impact of a good rock song is longer lasting. For example a lot of people listen to the Beatles which were big in the 60's. The song I know you want me by Pitbull was quite popular a year back but barely anyone listens to it that much anymore.
There those are the reasons as to why i prefer rock music to hip hop/pop. Dint get me ewrong i still listen to hop hop songs and i even like some of the its just that i like rock uch better. Iveput up a poll make sure u vote. If you agree with me tell me so. If you dont tell me why im wrong and give me solid reasons as to why you think so. Even better make a post on this on your blog and paste the link as a comment. If you liked the post follow me, spread the word and do all that good stuff :)
No comments:
Post a Comment